Skip to content
Upptäck praktiska råd, livsstilsinspiration och personliga …

Guardians Who Record Their Children Weeping for Clicks Must Examine at Themselves

A certain tune has been residing in my head the past seven days, and it's not, it isn't from the pop star's latest album. It originates by a much more sophisticated composer: a children's entertainer. The song is named Big Feelings and its words go: “Big feelings are OK / I’m here to stay with your big feelings.”

The Emergence of Intense Reactions On Social Media

Because of the popularity for conscious parenting, the concept of “big feelings” has become profitable digitally, and generally I welcome that. For caregivers, intense emotions are difficult to escape: you are experiencing them, the little one in your house is feeling them and, in one of the largest shifts for us as a humanity, so are countless other children on your digital streams.

Truly, videos of babies and children weeping is so commonplace on certain platforms that numerous parents don't even question it. I do not use TikTok and my Instagram feed is mostly centered around soup and witchcraft, but when a friend expressed that she found the phenomenon alarming, not to mention ethically questionable, I watched some of the recordings myself.

What I Saw: Children at Their Most Vulnerable

What I discovered was recording after recording of children at their most fragile. Weeping, shouting, shrieking, and sometimes acting out. I have naturally been present to these situations in my own home, but observing a different child going through it feels profoundly disturbing, particularly when that child is not being comforted by their own parent. Most unacceptable is a genre of video in which mothers subject their children to sinus clearing while their infant or young child sobs and yells right into the recording. It is important to mention that most of the videos are not like that, and yet there is nonetheless something horrible about them all.

In Cases Where Strong Emotions Do Not Become Distressing

Certainly, “big feelings” aren't always entirely upsetting. When your child is sprawling on the pavement upset at the understanding that sweets don't last forever it can be challenging to remain serious. Numerous of us have been told tales of especially memorable outbursts of our own. My own featured screaming “GIVE ME ALL YOUR MONEY!” in the lobby of the a modern art venue in downtown. Lightheartedly joking your child about a time they had a tantrum, or laughing about it with your partner once they have gone to bed, is acceptable. Filming a child in a moment of distress and sharing it to the online world for all to see lacking approval is a distinct concern altogether.

Disturbing Practices and Shaming

Furthermore you have the trends that are plainly unpleasant, such as one that involved shocking babies to stop crying by throwing a slice of cheese at their faces, or breaking an egg on them. That kind of content looks aimed at embarrassing children. In a piece for the a newspaper, a journalist stated: “The eeriest part of these videos [is that] the parents are barely engaging with their kids. Instead they are relating to a digital version of their children that they are disseminating online. And they are reveling in their authority over that image.”

The Defense of Teachability

There are video producers who would despise this kind of content. They claim that they are capturing their children at their most exposed not to ridicule them, but because they are attempting to create teachable moments – “see how calmly and effectively I was able to defuse this child’s tantrum using these strategies”. Some even try to stave off certain criticism. “This video is shared to inform and raise awareness – not for endorsement or judgments”, a particular clip, shared by an account managed by a medical professional, reportedly reads. The declaration that ensues is one of the most self-congratulatory nonsense I have read on the web. “If you don’t live the life, don’t judge the moment.”

A Question of Obligation

Why not you refrain from sharing the moment? I can't help but ask. Because I absolutely question these people. What I see, when I view a video of a small child in turmoil, whether their parent is performing comfort or not, is a dereliction of duty – the duty to be attentive for your child. And I ponder what implication it conveys, when when your child demonstrates a “big feeling”, you start recording. What message does that send to your baby about their entirely expected emotions? “Sharing real moments is part of the learning”, reportedly.

Considerations on Parenting Approaches

As my partner and I commence visiting schools for our youngster, it’s difficult not to reflect on how methods to upbringing have changed since we were children. There is an increased awareness of the fact that “big feelings” are par for the course for youngsters. Nowadays a lot of adults try to validate those emotions and give children a secure environment in which to share their feelings. But regardless of what the gentle parenting influencers state, I don’t believe you can genuinely give a secure environment for your child if you are recording their times of vulnerability and breaching their confidentiality and integrity in the process. If I’m honest, I cannot see these people have much to teach any of us about upbringing.

A Closing Reflection

There are some who will find that extreme, who would recoil from the fact that in certain respects I’d sooner put a cheese slice on my child's face for a joke than use his anguish as a learning opportunity for clicks. But to them I would say this: if “all behavior is communication”, what, specifically, are these parents attempting to communicate?

About the author

Rebecca Bradley

Elin är en svensk livsstilsbloggare med passion för mindfulness och hållbarhet, och hon delar erfarenheter från sitt eget livsresa.

Livsvinklar

Type to search articles.